Metro Philly Sports Network Logo

Why the Phillies should explore a Brandon Marsh trade

After joining the Phillies in the summer of 2022, Brandon Marsh has become a quality player for the Phillies.

Posted

It was a tale of two halves for Philadelphia Phillies outfielder Brandon Marsh this past season.

In the first half of 2026, Marsh was one of the best players in Major League Baseball. He earned his first All-Star nomination and started for the National League in front of his home crowd. The veteran left-hander had seemingly figured out how to hit left-handed pitching.

Marsh had arrived.

Then, in the second half of the season, he crashed.

Marsh was statistically one of the worst hitters in Major League Baseball. He returned to a platoon role, rather than the every day starter role he had earned. Marsh, much like everyone else, was left wondering what happened.

The Athletic's Matt Gelb recently reported that the veteran outfielder had surgery on his left hand/wrist right after the conclusion of the club's season. He reportedly dealt with an ailment for a majority of the season, which led to the procedure. 

Phillies outlook

Despite Marsh's success in his Phillies tenure, Philadelphia's outfield has been one of the worst overall units in Major League Baseball the past few seasons.

Without a doubt, the group needs a massive overhaul if the Phillies look to remain a World Series contender.

It would be safe to say that over the past several seasons, Marsh has been the club's best outfielder. This excludes Kyle Schwarber, who has become a primary designated hitter in recent seasons.

Marsh has accumulated 9.2 bWar in his 4.5 seasons in Philly. He has hit for .267 average with a .766 OPS across his 597 games.

Typically when you have a poor unit, you look to upgrade the weakest link, not the strongest. However, the Phillies have to make a decision on Marsh sooner rather than later, which is why I believe they should look to make a trade.

He enters the final year of his contract with the Phillies in 2027. Marsh is in his final season of arbitration, which means his salary is currently undefined. 

Brandon Marsh

With one year left on his contract, Marsh is expected to receive an arbitration offer of approximately $10 million this season. If the Phillies allowed Marsh to play this season under those terms, it would be worthy of his quality of play.

However, with potential corner outfield options in free agency available, it may benefit the Phillies to try and trade Marsh to upgrade in other areas.

If moving Marsh could land Philly another big league reliever for instance, it would allow them to upgrade in another weak area. 

Per reports, the Phillies have interest in Japanese sensation Teruaki Sato, 3x All-Star Randy Arozarena and veteran outfielder Seiya Suzuki.

If the Phillies add one of these players, they'll likely fill a corner outfield role. Sato and Arozarena would play left, Suzuki has more experience in right. By making a signing of this level, the Phillies would expect this addition to transform their outfield into an improved offensive force.

In order to add one of these options, the Phillies will need to spend a lot of money. Moving on from Marsh could free up some additional funds, but reopen a vacancy in the outfield.

One of the three outfield starting roles will be reserved for Justin Crawford, who had a quality rookie season. Crawford left plenty of room for improvement, but the Phillies organization anticipates the young outfielder will get another chance in centerfield.

Potential suitors

Several teams would be interested in obtaining Marsh's services for the 2027 season.

The Chicago Cubs could be a suitor for Marsh as both of their corner outfielders in Suzuki and Ian Happ, are free agents.

Assuming Chicago does not bring either back, Marsh could fill a void and join reigning MVP Pete Crow-Armstrong in the outfield of Wrigley Field.

Staying in the National League Central, another club who would benefit from adding Marsh is the St. Louis Cardinals. 

St. Louis had the 26th most fWar among all outfields in 2026. This was of course paired with a breakout season from Jordan Walker. Adding a player like Marsh would give the Cardinals a chance to take the next step towards contention, something they nearly did this past season.

Out west, the Houston Astros are in need of an outfield upgrade. Excluding Yordan Alvarez, who is primarily a designated hitter, the Astros have plenty of room for improvement with the overall unit.

Houston won the American League West again this season but are staring at an uncertain future. With older players like Jose Altuve and Carlos Correa, Houston may look to push the pedal towards contention once more. Adding Marsh would become an investment in a win-now mentality.

Brandon Marsh is a quality player who will positively impact a club in 2027. Whether or not that team plays in Philadelphia remains to be seen.


MORE: Kyle Schwarber wins second Silver Slugger Award


Philadelphia Phillies, Brandon Marsh, MLB, Offseason